Views of contemporary Muslim thinkers

Remembering Shariati (1933-77)

Janius Banaji writes on FB:
 Looking at him you’d scarcely guess that this suave figure inspired a whole generation of Iranian youth to turn to radical Left politics which included the kind of insurrectionary politics associated then with the Mojahedin-e Khalq, an armed struggle group that sought to reconcile a modernist version of Islam with left-wing ideas of social justice and anti-capitalism. That organization split in 1975 into Muslim and Marxist (Maoist) wings respectively, with bloody recriminations between them. Shariati continued to lend public support to the Muslim side of this split, while calling for an end to ‘sectarian hatreds’ between the two groups.
Shariati was not a Marxist by any stretch of the imagination, but he *was* a socialist from a very early age, a revolutionary, a brilliant and passionate lecturer who could speak for hours to a riveted audience, and also ‘strongly influenced by Marxism’, having studied in Paris in the early sixties and absorbed a range of influences from Sartre’s existentialism to Gurvitch’s Marxist sociology, Fanon’s writings on anti-colonialism, and the more academic work of his teacher the orientalist Louis Massignon.
Shariati was throughout his life a deeply committed Muslim but his Shi‘ism was of a radical, revolutionary type, thoroughly anti-clerical in its opposition to what he called ‘Safavid Shi‘ism’ (as opposed to his own ‘Red Shi‘ism’), the kind of Islam that disarmed the masses through its passive complicity with the ruling classes. Given that in modern Iran the clergy depended on the financial support of the richer merchants (bazaaris), Shariati’s ‘visceral contempt for the bourgeoisie’ extended to the ulama as well. His lectures and writings enraged the clerics, especially the influential group that saw in Khomeini the true face of the ‘revolutionary’ movement against Muhammad Reza Shah, and led to repeated fatwas condemning him after the revolution.
Ali Rahnema has written a great biography of Shariati, while the best account of the Mojahedin is Abrahamian’s book Radical Islam published in 1989. Currently Shariati’s Collected Works (in Persian) run to well over 35 volumes. These contain the major lectures he gave to students at the Hosseiniyeh Ershad in the early seventies, leading major clerics like Motahhari to complain (repeatedly to Khomeini) that he was ‘too much of an extremist’. He was imprisoned in September 1973, in the notorious Komiteh prison and in solitary confinement there; released 18 months later in March 1975 and then closely watched by SAVAK for the remaining 2 years that he stayed on in Iran. He left for England in May 1977, and died of a heart attack in Southampton two months later, on 19 June, so that today marks the 39th anniversary of his death.
The last 2 years of Shariati’s life saw him deeply disillusioned and engaged in a process of rethinking that was never brought to completion. For example, with the Mojahedin disintegrating and much of its organization decimated by arrests and executions, Shariati sought to discourage armed struggle as doomed to failure when the political work of working with the masses hadn’t even begun. These last writings (circulated by the state!) are discussed by Rahnema in his biography with no false claims about unbeaten heroism.
A note of caution; one of the few collections in English of Shariati’s writings bears the misleading title Marxism and Other Western Fallacies. As Abrahamian notes in several of his books on Iran, Shariati himself published no such collection and the title is not his but the tendentious choice of a group of California-based ‘admirers’ keen on downplaying his sympathy for Marx .  click here

More from Ideas

Muslims are strange people!

Professor Thomas S. Harrington (professor of Iberian Studies at Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut) writes in counterpunch.org After the bombing in Manchester and the bridge attack in London, it is more clear than ever: Muslims are very strange people, inherently violent … read more

Is there a ‘Muslim world’?

Asma Afsaruddin, Professor of Islamic studies in the School of Global and International Studies at Indiana University at Bloomington,  reviews Cemil Aydin’s The Idea of the Muslim World: A Global Intellectual History in The Chronicle of Higher Education: . . … read more

More on Balfour

Salman Abu Sitta’s address at the UK’s House of Lords [28 March 2017, from middleeastmonitor.com], ‘We are witnessing today the longest war against a people: A hundred years of the Palestinian people’s struggle for freedom and independence in their own country. … read more

Thoughts on Bosnia

trtworld.com interviews the former Grand Mufti of Bosnia Herzegovina, Mustafa Ceric: 1.  The country is still recovering from the effects of the Bosnian War, a deadly conflict between Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina and those of the Bosnian Serb and Bosnian … read more

The Geopolitics of Culture

Extracts from an essay by Nayef Al-Rodhan, neuroscientist and geo-strategist,  in the Harvard International Review, entitled ‘The Geopolitics of Culture: Five Substrates’. ‘Culture has a salient geopolitical relevance in a world that defines itself by much more than diplomatic exchanges … read more

The Rise & Decline of Pax Americana

In the second part of  ‘The history of Capitalism – a personal view’, Muhammad Nauman Khan explores the emergence of the USA’s “uni-polarity” and the eventual disappointing outcome of the ‘American dream’, adding There is an erosion of US economic and … read more

Deconstructing ‘Radicalisation’

Extracts from an interview with Assistant Professor Nadia Fadil of KU Leuven, Belgium: Radicalisation is a contested notion, due to its exclusive focus on Islam. Yet, radical thinking in itself is not necessarily problematic or undesirable. For example, the early … read more

Muhammad Nauman Khan’s wide-ranging essay on economic history – Part II. The Rise and Decline of Pax Americana Over one hundred years ago, in 1905, the United States’ gross domestic product per head first overtook Great Britain’s, making it the world’s biggest … read more